About Fitzroyalty

Fitzroyalty - hyperlocal news and reviews about Melbourne’s first suburb: Fitzroy 3065 - is a local news site for Fitzroy residents and visitors. Read the about and hyperlocal pages for more information.

It features stories on the suburb of Fitzroy in Melbourne, Australia, and reflections on life from a socially libertarian, economically socialist, culturally anarchistic and radically individualistic point of view.

"I hate almost everything you write yet I cannot look away. You’re better than [Andrew] Bolt." User comment.

Email: brian [at] indolentdandy.net

Copyright license

Creative Commons License
Fitzroyalty - a hyperlocal blog about Melbourne’s first suburb: Fitzroy 3065 by Brian Ward is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 Australia License.

Subscribe to feeds

RSS2 excerpt feeds are available for you to syndicate as per the CC license.

All posts

Fitzroy posts

Comments

Recent comments

Recently updated

Archives

there’s no such thing as excessive force

We live in a society that is soft on violent crime. We excuse aggressive behaviour and do not allow people to adequately protect themselves, their families and their property from assault without fear of being prosecuted for their defensive response.

In a recent case a Sydney man used a whip to defend his property, his family and party guests from violent gatecrashers. He has been warned that he may be charged with the use of excessive force in defending himself. This is nonsense. There should be no such thing as a charge of excessive force for self defence. The right to defend yourself, your family and your property from within the boundaries of your property should be absolute.

The gatecrashers trespassed on the man’s property, damaged his property, then acted as a group to assault him. Only then did he use a weapon (a whip) to defend himself and drive them from his property. If you break the law by trespassing on someone’s property, refuse a request to leave, then attack the property and its owner, you should lose all legal rights.

The property owner should be able to defend themselves however they can. The property owner should be free to act as necessary to make themselves safe, to beat, stab, shoot or attack an intruder with an axe or whatever they can get their hands on to defend themselves. I would give this homeowner a bravery medal.

There is no ethical right to violate the safety and rights of others and yet have your own safety and rights respected. What would Keith Richards or Andrew Symonds do? If there’s nutters on your turf you need to chop them down. Criminal thugs need to understand the consequences of their actions.

In a related case in Perth a man who ignored security and danger signs and illegally trespassed on a power utility’s fenced and secured property is suing the company after being electrocuted on the property and losing both his legs. He got what he deserved.

So did the Sydney thugs. I wish they had been permanently crippled by the homeowner. They should then be denied access to government funded health and welfare services because they obtained their injuries while committing a crime. The should live in pain and poverty and hopefully die young. They are parasites and a blight on society.

You might also like

Atherton Gardens heroin arrests
So the regular complaints from some Atherton Gardens residents were correct: tenants in flats in the...
give this man a medal
Update 19 September 2009: there is an update on this case here. I'd like to nominate a man for Australian...
why should we pay to placate irrational behaviour?
According to this article, Orthodox Jews in Melbourne who fail to use pedestrian crossings lawfully have...

Other posts you may find relevant and interesting

One Response to “there’s no such thing as excessive force”

  1. Michael Lee Says:

    I wish I’d had a whip at my 18th…to whip any drunk girl who tried to put on Jagged Little Pill…

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

You own the copyright of your comment. By submitting your comment you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.