About Fitzroyalty

Fitzroyalty - hyperlocal news and reviews about Melbourne’s first suburb: Fitzroy 3065 - is a local news site for Fitzroy residents and visitors. Read the about and hyperlocal pages for more information.

It features stories on the suburb of Fitzroy in Melbourne, Australia, and reflections on life from a socially libertarian, economically socialist, culturally anarchistic and radically individualistic point of view.

"I hate almost everything you write yet I cannot look away. You’re better than [Andrew] Bolt." User comment.

Email: brian [at] indolentdandy.net

Copyright license

Creative Commons License
Fitzroyalty - a hyperlocal blog about Melbourne’s first suburb: Fitzroy 3065 by Brian Ward is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 Australia License.

Subscribe to feeds

RSS2 excerpt feeds are available for you to syndicate as per the CC license.

All posts

Fitzroy posts

Comments

Recent comments

Recently updated

Archives

skank is as skank does

Brunswick St women’s fashion shop IDS commissioned artist Deb some time ago to paint some of her signature female figures on their shop door and doorway. On a recent weekend walk I noticed that someone had added to her work and I am not sure how I feel about it.

One way to see it is to be annoyed because this is bad for the business that paid for Deb’s work. However, it’s not a stupid tag and cannot immediately be dismissed as worthless vandalism. Where does creative license begin and end? When is commentary like this justified and when is it inappropriate or disrespectful to the artist? More importantly, is the critique aimed at the clothes, the customers or the art?

You might also like

Fitzroy art criticism
Artist Deb has been attracting a lot of attention recently. Her commissioned work at IDS on Brunswick...
a conspiracy of criticism
Update 24 June 2009: I should have mentioned this before but I spoke with Deb today and she asked me...
new Deb at IDS
Deb has replaced her artworks on the wall and door of IDS on Brunswick St with some fantastic sultry...

Other posts you may find relevant and interesting

3 Responses to “skank is as skank does”

  1. Amber Says:

    Is this work considered graffiti? If so, I don’t think the addition is disrespectful.

    This has prompted some thoughts on graffiti art in general. I love graffiti art. I love strolling through the city and viewing graffiti art. Now I see graffiti artists shifting into galleries and for me it takes the art out of context. I don’t love it as much when I see it in a gallery. For me I no longer consider it as graffiti art, its just art. So now I am confused. Is the objective then only to make money? What does the word graffiti mean, what is the criteria? Personally, part of the rush of seeing a new fabulous work on a wall, is because it’s in the public domain, its accessible, it mingles with the other works to become almost a collaborative piece. In a gallery it stands alone and with a price tag. It can therefore be purchased and never seen again by the public.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  2. jessy Says:

    Its deffinately an immature act of jealousy, Debs work is everywhere and mostly well respected. She is an amazing artist, I met her recently at one of her shows and she is one of the nicest people I’ve ever met. I am a big fan of her work. I think the one that tagged over it is deffinately the skank. You can always tell when something is an act of jealousy and in this case most deffinately. Big Up Deb! Always lookin out for new stuff.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1

  3. lola Says:

    amber, in alot of cases, artists start of sketching painting or drawing before they move onto graff. graff is a passion for me but i have been painting since i was young so i see what your saying BUT sometimes you are willing to sell some of your work to beable to fund painting on the street. you do realise a can of paint is 8-12 bucks and you only fund that out of your own pocket if you never sell a piece of artwork. also seeing it in a gallery context is simply another take on the art its good to have a balance of both. i hope you begin to understand where we are coming from as graffers who exhibit, a lot of people see it as selling out but its one of those things…if you really dont understand maybe you shouldnt comment.
    as for this, every single time a girl comes on the graff scene there is this sort of disrespect and i definately think its jealousy most probably from other girls who wish they could have the balls and the talent to do it.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1

Leave a Reply

You own the copyright of your comment. By submitting your comment you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.